métis

14 Mar 2022 - 14 Oct 2026
Open in Logseq
    • A Greek term meaning rougly "cunning intelligence", as distinct from the more abstract rational kind. It is both more situated and contextual, and metarational in that a wielder of metis applies the appropriate tools to a situation.
    • In 2022 I wanted to name my imaginary intelligent assistant "metis". Maybe I still will, the think I'm building has many names (see KnowOS ).
    • 2015

      • This was in response to Gyrus on WS Discord
      • I know "bricoleur" as the best French translation of "hacker". Hacker culture was (and maybe still is) a kind of alternative relationship to technology than the standard rationalist engineering mindset. A hacker has a more improvisational, scruffy, inhabiting approach. Might be hard to relate to in this era of large, powerful, capitalized tech but it wasn't always like this. Anyway I could go on about this at length, hacking is kind of my home turf.
      • For anyone else into the métis thing, I've realised bricolage is a really interesting related or parallel term. Levi-Strauss's famous use contrasted its improvisatory quality with the engineer working from plans, which very much fits with métis. There's an interesting discussion of bricolage in relation to ideas of creativity from Bergson in Tim Ingold's introduction to Creativity and Cultural Improvisation (2007). Bonus WS points for a Deleuze appearance - in Anti-Oedipus, bricolage is the schizophrenic mode of production.
    • 2013

      • Appears in Seeing Like a State? Ah yes
        • Kollontay’s point of departure, like Luxemburg’s, is an assumption about what kinds of tasks are the making of revolutions and the creating of new forms of production. For both of them, such tasks are voyages in uncharted waters. There may be some rules of thumb, but there can be no blueprints or battle plans drawn up in advance; the numerous unknowns in the equation make a one-step solution inconceivable. In more technical language, such goals can be approached only by a stochastic process of successive approximations, trial and error, experiment, and learning through experience. The kind of knowledge required in such endeavors is not deductive knowledge from first principles but rather what Greeks of the classical period called métis, a concept to which we shall return. Usually translated, inadequately, as “cunning,” métis is better understood as the kind of knowledge that can be acquired only by long practice at similar but rarely identical tasks, which requires constant adaptation to changing circumstances. It is to this kind of knowledge that Luxemburg appealed when she characterized the building of socialism as “new territory” demanding “improvisation” and “creativity.”