• AMMDI is an open-notebook hypertext writing experiment, authored by Mike Travers aka @mtraven. It's a work in progress and some parts are more polished than others. Comments welcome! More.
Incoming links
from Marx
  • A paragon of conflict theory. And of group agency as well – a lot of Marxism is about the agency of classes, although not quite explicitly. I'm on shaky ground, but my understanding is that that is what is meant by [class consciousness]
    • While German theorist Karl Marx rarely used the term "class consciousness", he did make the distinction between "class in itself", which is defined as a category of people having a common relation to the means of production; and a "class for itself", which is defined as a stratum organized in active pursuit of its own interests.
from Voting
from conspiracy theory
  • Conspiracy theories are usually bad theories of group agency; they postulate some shadowy group that is pulling the strings of the world. They flourish in part because we lack good theories of agency.
from agency
from swarming
from Patterns of Refactored Agency
  • A common pathological form of group agency attribution is the conspiracy theory, in which people imagine coordinated group activity where none exists.
from Agency: notes and references
  • Introduces the term "Social Mass" which I guess is a theory of group agency
    • What is understood as a “Social Mass”? It is, summarily, a term that describes any form of collective arrangement emanating and arising from certain Ideals which are thought, defined and imposed as taking precedence over the “individual”. A Social Mass, here, is a descriptor for the many social groups of unrelated people who are perceived as sharers of a set of core characteristics that they hold to be in some form integral to their definition as beings
from Patterns of Refactored Agency
  • Clumping or group agency means thinking about the agency of collections of people (so it is the dual of splitting). This too is a pretty common trope. Corporations, states, nations, and other human groupings are often treated as if they have agency of their own. Even the law treats corporations as persons.
Twin Pages

group agency

10 Feb 2021 06:46 - 01 Jan 2022 07:48

    • Nature (the Art whereby God hath made and governes the World) is by the Art of man, as in many other things, so in this also imitated, that it can make an Artificial Animal… For by Art is created that great LEVIATHAN called a COMMON-WEALTH, or STATE (in latine CIVITAS) which is but an Artificiall Man; though of greater stature and strength than the Naturall, for whose protection it was intended.
      • – Hobbes, Leviathan
    • The agency of collections of people, including nations, corporations, and other groups of humans. This is basically the subject matter of huge chunks of political philosophy and social science, so there has been a lot of thinking about this. I'm not sure if I have anything new to say about it.
    • Further reading

      • Marx[ists] on class consciousness, which is a particular kind of group agency, and they have a specialized language to talk about it.
      • Crazyism
        • For instance, Schwitzgebel tries to demonstrate that a consistent materialism must grant consciousness to collective entities:
        • It would be bizarre to suppose that the United States has a stream of conscious experience distinct from the conscious experiences of the people who compose it...Yet it’s unclear by what materialist standard the United States lacks consciousness. Nations, it would seem, represent and self-represent. They respond (semi-) intelligently and self- protectively, in a coordinated way, to opportunities and threats. They gather, store, and manipulate information. They show skillful attunement to environmental inputs in warring and spying on each other. Their subparts (people and subgroups of people) are massively informationally interconnected and mutually dependent, including in incredibly fancy self-regulating feedback loops. These are the kinds of capacities and structures that materialists typically regard as the heart of mentality.
      • A blog post on group personhood from a conservative philosopher Edward Feser: Corporate persons
        • I'm guessing this stuff is deeply stupid but good to know about.
        • Scruton also notes that some corporate persons can be utterly malign, such as the Nazi and Communist parties. By my analogy, such corporate persons may be likened to damned and impenitent souls...A corporate person could instead be infallible, as Catholics claim the Church is. That doesn’t mean that the individual members cannot err, including the pope when he is not speaking ex cathedra. It means that the “mind of the Church” as a corporate person cannot fall into error, and the reason a pope cannot err when speaking ex cathedra is that in such an act he is giving definitive expression to the mind of the Church.
      • Stewardship of global collective behavior | PNAS
        • Scholars have long sought to understand the mechanisms by which groups of individuals accomplish collective action (1, 2, 26). This phenomenon has been studied in a variety of disciplines, from anthropology, social psychology, sociology, political science, management, communication studies, economics, animal behavior, and sociobiology, to computer science, statistical physics, and the emerging domain of computational social science (2735). These disciplines are largely differentiated by methods, scale of organization, and whether they study aspects of contemporary Homo sapiens society.